Asia Healthcare Blog
Exploring the intersection of investment and development, in Asia



China, HK, Macau

October 3, 2011

9000 Needles [VIDEO]: Inspirational American w/out insurance gets scammed, finds peace in China

stem cell clinic scams, worst chinese hospital, TCM scams, traditional chinese medicine

Devin Dearth, the inspirational figure behind the Devin Dearth Foundation, used to be a body builder, but not the kind that take so many steroids they end up looking like Watusi longhorn cattle. Rather, according to his doctor, “[Devin] took health to a level most individuals don’t even dream about.” In the footage taken of Devin before his stroke he is smiling and his family seems happy. After Devin’s stroke, everything changed.  The Dearth family’s subsequent struggles are capture in the film “9000 Needles,” which won several best documentary at the 2010 Phoenix Film Festival.

Why then, is the title about a large number of needles? Because in what had to be a moment of desperation after finding out that Devin’s insurance would no longer cover rehab at their American hospital, Devin’s brother decides that the family should take Dearth to China for traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) treatment. TCM, as you may know, involves acupuncture.

9000 Needles Trailer from Fallout Entertainment on Vimeo.

I’ve written before about my disdain for Chinese scam hospitals which market miracle treatments for strokes and degenerative disease of the brain to Western patients easily charmed by their perceived exoticism of traditional Chinese medicine.  So I shouldn’t need to point out a spoiler alert when I tell you that  the treatment did not repair Dearth’s stroke-damaged brain and spinal chord (but I will point out that it did result in his profile being put up on this scam stem cell hospital’s website). But the movie’s value does not lie in its portrayal of one Chinese hospital profiting on its false promises. Instead the film’s focus on how the trip brings a broken family together is a reminder that many times the value of chasing miracles lies in the journey. Devin’s most successful treatments in China came during the period away from the dingy TCM offices.

 



About the Author

Damjan Denoble
Damjan co-founded Asia Healthcare Blog with James Flanagan, in 2009. He is currently a JD/MA dual-degree student in Law and Chinese Studies, at The University of Michigan Law School. Last summer he clerked at the offices of Harris & Moure, a boutique international law firm widely admired for its China Law Blog. He graduated from Duke University in 2007, with a B.A. in Public Policy, concentration in health policy.




0 Comments


Be the first to comment!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>