Asia Healthcare Blog
Exploring the intersection of investment and development, in Asia



China, HK, Macau

August 25, 2010

China’s quack doctors are not afraid to hire someone who’ll hurt you, or me

Fang Xuanchang is a respected Chinese science and technology journalist who was recently beaten by two men he suspects were thugs hired by an angry doctor he exposed in a story. The incident suggests a new enemy to journalists in a nation filled with government press crackdowns: vindictive story subjects who hire mobsters to seek revenge. Photograph by: John M. Glionna, Los Angeles Times/MCT

A year or so ago we did a post on a Chinese hospital that was offering stem cell “cures” for disease like Alzheimers and various paralytic diseases.  Someone claiming to be from the Chinese hospital we referred to in that piece – Beijing TianTian Puhua Hospital, in Beijing (they have a great website explaining exactly how they plan to scam you) -  sent us a “cease and desist” type email through our contact form.  We don’t know if it really was Tian Tian Puhua.  In fact, I’m hopeful for their patients sake that they can do better than an anonymous, badly misspelled email that’s only about a paragraph long.  Whatever the origin of the email, our coverage of the fake stem cell practice touched a nerve with someone.

 

Well, all I can say is, boy it’s good to be in the US of A, where I can safely say, “Go F[ine and self regulate] yourself [better] TianTian Puhua Hospital in Beijing for taking suffering people’s money and feeding them false hope.”  I really hate to get half-way to vulgar like I just did, but medical predators make me so angry.

Then, today, I picked up on this touching article from the Vancouver Sun about Fang Xuanchang, a Chinese investigative reporter who specializes in reporting on quack doctors and false hope operations.  Mr. Fang got his head beaten in by lead piping by thugs as he was walking home one evening, all because he was uncovering doctors committing crimes against unwitting patients.

Could have been me, I guess.

The lessons for readers are 1) to always, always, always get more than one recommendation for a doctor when you’re in China, 2) if you’re going to have surgery in China, and you have the time to plan it out but don’t have time to hop on a plane and go back home, have a Western doctor at one of the International SOS clinics or a private, English-speaking staff hospital recommend a doctor for you to see, and 3) figure out what hospital you would want to be taken to in case of an emergency, and have it written down on something that will be on your person at all times.

As a matter of fact, follow the above advice (slightly modified for context) wherever you’re living.  Bad doctors are everywhere.

And, of course, if you don’t have to, then don’t go around busting quack doctors in countries where that kind of work is quickly silenced.



About the Author

Damjan Denoble
Damjan co-founded Asia Healthcare Blog with James Flanagan in 2009. He is currently a law student in his second year at The University of Michigan Law School. Last summer he clerked at the offices of Harris & Moure, a boutique international law firm widely admired for its China Law Blog. He graduated from Duke University in 2007, with a B.A. in Public Policy, concentration in health policy.




2 Comments


  1. Someone thinks this story is fantastic…

    This story was submitted to Hao Hao Report – a collection of China’s best stories and blog posts. If you like this story, be sure to go vote for it….


  2. A friend of mine almost had his face permanently f#cked up by Chinese hospitals after insisting his broken jaw wasn’t broken, read the whole story here, a good read, but only if you’re into reading about shocking incompetence and corruption.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


 
lcd screen laptop