Posted By Damjan DeNoble
China’s parallel markets are familiar to anyone who’s done business here.
For those who haven’t been on that adventure, China’s rural market is characterized by small mom and pop shops, outside bazaars where farmers sell all manner of goods, local made products such as three wheeled vehicles fitted with tractor motors, and back-room electronics brands that imitate the design of famous best sellers like Ipods. In short, its a combination of neighborhood businesses with few further aspirations for growth, and ambitious businesses with hopes of one day going international.
The other market is the international one where China’s top business ventures compete with Fortune 500 companies from all over the world. Clearly segmented from the rural markets, the dealers of these international quality services tend to bunch together in centers of wealth like expansive malls, and glassed-in car dealerships - if all the people and Chinese signage were to disappear from these places it would be impossible for a person to guess what country she was in.
From marketing houses to coffee houses, this partitioned competition is everywhere and can spell trouble for businesses that don’t understand it well – just ask Wal-Mart. Meanwhile, some of the most succesful businesses in China, Yum! Foods, and 7-11 come to mind right away, are able to offer international market standard service and product, at local market prices, operating at or near the ‘middle of the parallel’, thus cashing in on both expat and rich Chinese dollars, who tend to shop international; as well as lower middle class Chinese, who tend to shop local. When it comes down to it, these innovative businesses are what travelers write home and facebook about, “Facebook Sweetpee is… Whoaah! 7-11 is so much better in Beijing than in Durham! It’s really crazy guys, you gotta come out here!”
(Jack Perkowski, author of the stellar book Manage the Dragon and the blog of the same name, as well as mythological China expat force, explains this much better than I could, because I…well…learned how to see and describe this phenomenon by reading his books and his blog- so start here to get a fuller explanation of parallel markets, otherwise buy his book)
If this is the case, then where are the ‘middle of the parallel’ health industry innovators?
If this is the case, then where are the ‘middle of the parallel, health industry innovators? China has the high end hospital chains – (Parkway Health and United Health Systems); it has the private clinics offering proven international standard outpatient care (International SOS); and, it has the private clinics that offer services specialized to the needs of the local high income populations, like vamped up physician and OBGYN services.
But, why is there nowhere I can go for a basic consultation that offers me local health care rates (20-100 RMB per consultation) yet provides me with a clean environment and an english speaking medical staff ? If scaling up 50RMB (about $7) check ups to a profit is possible anywhere in the world, it should be possible in China.
For the sake of example, here is a brief outline for how it could be done:
Set up ‘retail clinics’ which offer a limited range of services, such as check ups for non-serious conditions, and are linked to larger health care providers through a referral systemf for instances when a patient has something that needs more serious attention, like a suspect heart murmur. Go here for more information on the concept (it’s a .pdf).
Base your geographic strategy off a successful model like Minute Clinic. Partner with a Chinese pharmacy chain, or any other modern Chinese neighborhood staple, like 7-11, to have private clinics inside the store.
Strive for a quick entry and exit model of 5 minutes per check up, and no more than 5 minutes of paperwork (billing and prescriptions), and just make sure that medical staff smile at the patient, and even encourage them to softly push 7-11s products, “The new triply fudge KING ice-cream bar is now available at this 7-11 location. It will help bring down your fever.”
Brand the clinic through an innovative social media strategy because the concept would be very social media friendly, sharing, as it does, many common characteristics of popular social media tools like twitter – namely, that it is fast, friendly, cutting edge, and easy to use. As I wrote about here, this could quickly ramp up the business.
Final bill for the consultation should be no more than a movie ticket (35-80 RMB) and the process just repeats throughout the day. Insurance is not accepted so that the clinics compete on a purely retail basis, which happens to be a familiar concept to all Chinese consumers (as opposed to private insurance, which is still very murky territory for most of the country).
The rent for the clinic space, and medical instruments (no more than 80 square meters needed) would be minimal and even at 50 patients per day (cold sufferers mostly) the gross revenue for one location could be between 45,000 RMB ($6700) and 104,000 RMB ($15,294) per month, not counting referral and pharmacy bonuses. With multiple locations throughout the country this model could become very profitable for anyone who decided to run with it.
Why are there not more health firms and entrepreneurs jumping all over this concept? I mean, its a very basic, Base of Pyramid concept. If this existed in Beijing, it would take a lot of stress away from being sick for me and many of my uninsured friends. I would even be willing to pay up to 150 RMB for a check up, as long as it was good and I could get ice cream afterwards.
Affordable, available, fast, and reputable, private health care with Chinese characteristics.
I would love to hear some ideas on this from people.

5 Comments
Damjan,
Nice analysis and commentary. The gap between the local and the international markets in health care is as wide as any product or service I have seen in my fifteen years in China. That is why it simply has to close, and why I consider health care in China to be one of the big opportunities going forward. Whether the specific ideas you mention are the right ones, I can’t comment. But, they’re heading in the right direction.
Thanks for referencing my ideas about the two markets in China and for mentioning my book and my blog. I appreciate it. While the “two markets” concept may seem simplistic, it’s amazing how many companies don’t understand and try to deal with it.
Jack
Thanks for posting these useful information. Keep them coming
@Jack Perkowski
Like you have pointed out, the “two markets” notion is very simplistic to grasp, but it is infinitely harder to put into practice. Even making use of the two market system is hard for a lot of people coming into China – shopping at Jenny Lou’s for everything, vegetables included, when JingKeLong’s vegetables are half as cheap and its selection much wider, is just one example.
I doubt very much my ideas are the right ones, but I thought I’d give it a shot as just an exercise of sorts. The things I am seeing going on in the health industry right now tell me that a wave of home grown innovation will be coming soon.
Lynn Nezin EVP, Business Development at White Space Healthcare Marketing commented on LinkedIn:
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/2/124/b50
I particularly enjoyed the concept of recommending an ice cream sundae at 7-11 to bring down fever. I have always been intrigued by a Chinese medical concept that may no longer be in fashion, that of paying the patient to stay well by not charging the patient when ill, based on the premise that if a patient became ill, the doctor was not doing his/her job. Given our new love affair with preventive medicine, that seems like a billing strategy that makes a lot of sense.
My response on LinkedIn:
Hopefully unlike love affairs, the current focus afforded to more cost efficient and patient friendly health care won’t fizzle out.
I read the other day, however, that some 60 or more CVS/Minute Clinic locations are closing down, so i really want to find out what happened there.
Whatever may turn out to be the case, I think opreating costs in China would make it easier for a concept like Minute Clinic to take off. And, if the Chinese are able to look inside themselves and really build a health system that upholds the principles of their ancient medical wisdom, then we might really see some cool stuff start coming out of its health industry.
3 Trackbacks
[...] due to these salary changes (more money saved earlier), China should start seeing a lot of health innovation. Old doctors depend on prestige for business. Young doctors are going to need to depend a lot [...]
[...] end hospital, but that there is hope for a more innovative health care delivery system in China (and, in a previous post, I have tried thinking through what that might look like). Moreover, I find solace in the fact that the Chinese government seems aware of the dangers that [...]
[...] Private Healthcare With Chinese Characteristics [...]